Volkswagen’s Response to Tax Penalty
Volkswagen, the German automobile giant, has filed a legal challenge against authorities in India, seeking to overturn a tax notice of $1.4 billion. Volkswagen's response to the tax penalty is that the demand is inconsistent with existing import tax policies in the country and could jeopardize its investment of $1.5 billion in India. The Bombay High Court is set to hear the case on February 5, 2025.
Read More: Indian Auto Sector Ser Indian Auto Sector Set to Grow in Clean Tech with Budget 2025
Volkswagen Tax Notice Against the Allegations By India
The Indian government issued the fine of VW in India in September 2024, accusing Volkswagen of misdeclaration and misclassification of vehicle imports. Authorities accused the company of importing nearly complete cars in an unassembled state but declaring them as individual parts to benefit from lower tax rates.
CKD units generally attract a 30-35% tax under Indian import regulations, while individual components attract a lower rate of 5-15%. VW paid in fines nearly $980 million in import duties since 2012 but should have paid around $2.35 billion, as calculated by the government.
Volkswagen’s Legal Action
Volkswagen tax notice is denied by the company, stating that it has been open about its import strategy since 2011 before Indian authorities. The company says tax demand is a very sharp U-turn that creates uncertainty for foreign investors.
In response to Volkswagen India tax evasion notice, the automaker further argues that its approach to importing is not to be considered bringing in complete vehicle kits but rather individual components, which it integrates with locally sourced parts into final assemblies. Volkswagen sought to compare its practice with buying a chair online in multiple shipments rather than receiving an entirely assembled product.
Impact on Investment and Foreign Confidence
The Volkswagen tax notice highlights policy inconsistency and lack of regulatory transparency in India. VW paid in fines a large sum of amount which is still not accurate as per Indian Government. Volkswagen has said that the tax dispute may hurt its long-term investment in the country and might deter other multinationals from expanding their operations in India.
Neither Volkswagen nor the Indian finance ministry has issued any official statement commenting on the ongoing litigation. This case is likely to be a landmark decision on tax-related disputes among foreign automakers operating in India.
